Under Oath, MI5 Officer Reveals Official British Torture Program

(noon. – promoted by ek hornbeck)

The UK Guardian, which has been right on top of the Binyam Mohamed drama unfolding in the British courts, delivered another bombshell article this morning in London. “Whitehall devised torture policy for terror detainees,” the headline reads, “MI5 interrogations in Pakistan agreed by lawyers and government.”

The British High Court resumed their hearing of Binyam’s request for documents to prove his torture, as part of the legal proceedings against him at Guantanamo. Previously, the British judges had ruled that what they called “powerful evidence” suppressed relating to the torture of Mohamed by the U.S. and their proxy torturers in Morocco, where Mohamed had been sent as part of the Bush Administration’s policy of “extraordinary rendition.” The judges then revealed that they had been told by the British Foreign Minister, David Milibrand, that the requested documents could not be released, or U.S.-UK intelligence relations would be affected.

From the article:

Miliband’s position in the affair came under renewed attack yesterday after it emerged that his officials solicited a letter from the US state department to back up his claim that if the evidence was disclosed, Washington might stop sharing intelligence with Britain….

Evidence heard by the court in-camera – once the public and the media had been excluded – resulted in Jacqui Smith, the home secretary, asking the attorney general, Lady Scotland, to investigate “possible criminal wrongdoing” by both American and British security and intelligence officers.

And what was that wrongdoing. According to an MI5 officer testifying anonymously before the British court, and named only “Witness B”. The Guardian reports that:

A number of British terrorism suspects who have been detained without trial in Pakistan say they were tortured by Pakistani intelligence agents before being questioned by MI5. In some cases their accusations are supported by medical evidence.

One of those suspects was Binyam Mohamed, who awaits a return from Guantanamo to Britain, terribly weakened by a months-long hunger strike. Witness B had interrogated Mr. Mohamed in Karachi, and in cross-examination by the court, the MI5 officer admitted that the prisoner had looked in “an extremely vulnerable position.” The witness also allowed that he told Mohamed that he’d “get more lenient treatment if he cooperated.”

The article continues:

Asked then whether the transfer concerned him, Witness B replied: “I was aware that the general question of interviewing detainees had been discussed at length by security service management legal advisers and government, and I acted in this case, as in others, under the strong impression that it was considered to be proper and lawful.” He denied that he had threatened Mohamed and said the prisoner appeared well enough to be questioned.

Mohamed was eventually able to tell lawyers that before being questioned by MI5 he had been hung from leather straps, beaten and threatened with a firearm by Pakistani intelligence officers. After the meeting with MI5 he was “rendered” to Morocco where he endured 18 months of even more brutal torture, including having his genitals slashed with a scalpel. Some of the questions put to him under torture in Morocco were based on information passed by MI5 to the US.

The Guardian has learned from other sources that the interrogation policy was directed at a high level within Whitehall and that it has been further developed since Mohamed’s detention in Pakistan. Evidence of this might emerge from 42 undisclosed US documents seen by the high court and sent to the MPs and peers on the intelligence and security committee (ISC).

As the details of the gory torture program leak out, it becomes clearer and clearer that the Obama administration’s refusal to declassify relevant documents in Binyam’s case amounts to a terrible cover-up of very serious war crimes. No matter what you think or want to think about Barack Obama, Eric Holder, and the rest of this new Democratic administration, they are treading very close to being implicated in war crimes. They should know this information will leak out, and to move now will save the U.S. credibility, and their own administration serious embarrassment or worse.

What is happening in Britain right now is sure to spill over to U.S. politics eventually, especially when the questions start to be “What did he know, and when did he know it”:

In a letter to the committee, Clive Stafford Smith, the director of Reprieve, says: “The ISC would want to know whether the intelligence services brought the issue of Mr Mohamed’s abuse to the attention of the prime minister (then Mr Blair) – and, if not, why not.” He said if the evidence had been brought to Blair’s attention, “the ISC would want to know what, if anything, was done about it. If nothing was done, that would raise serious questions about the respect that the UK government has for its obligations under the convention against torture.”

We must demand that the U.S. release all documents in the Binyam case immediately. The British government, too, must release what documentation they are holding in the Binyam Mohamed case. The time to come clean is now.

H/T Trudy Bond

3 comments

    • Valtin on February 17, 2009 at 18:55
      Author

    MI5 is fighting back, sort of, by claiming Britain’s Labor Party is creating a police state! I’m not kidding. (Meanwhile, the story is invisible in the U.S. press.)

    A FORMER MI5 chief today accused the Government of exploiting fears of terrorism to pass draconian laws as fresh allegations emerged of Britain’s complicity in torture.

    Dame Stella Rimington declared that ministers were playing into the hands of terrorists by curbing civil liberties. In an interview with a Spanish newspaper published today, Dame Stella said that the Government was “frightening people in order to be able to pass laws which restrict civil liberties, precisely one of the objects of terrorism: that we live in fear and under a police state”.

    Dame Stella, the first woman director general of MI5, has criticised Labour’s plans for ID cards and for the detention of terrorism suspects without charge for 42 days.

    She told La Vanguardia: “The US has gone too far with Guantanamo and the tortures. MI5 does not do that. Furthermore it has achieved the opposite effect: there are more and more suicide terrorists finding a greater justification”. She said British agents were “no angels” but insisted they did not kill people.

    Her remarks came amid new claims that senior Whitehall figures devised an interrogation policy for British secret service agents that allowed complicity with torture by other states.

  1. I am only able to be here at this site around an hour or two a week…..

    so I do not get a good chance to read all of the dialogue…

    you seem to be both intelligent and thoughtful…..

    from where I sit this appears to be a very old habit of ourselves…..

    nearly all cultures seem to have engaged in it at one time or another……

    can we as a species rise to a place where our culture will not have this a part of its inheritance……….

    I have become more and more cynical as time has passed….

  2. The time to come clean will be passed, as soon as it`s leaked about the “what did he know”, & the “when did he know it”, speaking of the president.

    I would have been quite satisfied for him to declare an end to all the ongoing policies that may have the appearance of impropriety (major understatement), & announce that investigations would begin immediately with a directive to Mr. Holder, AG, to appoint an independent special prosecutor, to that effect.

    Investigations that would specifically be undertaken to root out all crimes, no matter the levels it may reach into the previous administration, concerning torture, enhanced interrogation techniques, & who were involved & how they purported to have achieved the standard which essentially made their acts legal.

    People have died as a direct result of some of these horrendous acts. I do not believe the time to act will pass. There is now till the end of time during which the truth will come out. With your incredible efforts, I believe we will not have to wait that long. Thank you for being a steady wind in the turbulence of this sea of lies. I believe your unrelenting efforts, along with others fighting the same battle are having an incremental effect on the people who can disseminate it, every time another truth is exposed.

Comments have been disabled.