Levin To Holder: Appoint An Independent Investigator On Torture

From Think Progress

Responding to a question earlier this month, President Obama didn’t rule out the possibility of appointing a special prosecutor to “independently investigate” the “greatest crimes” committed by the Bush administration. But he said that his “orientation” was “to look forward as opposed to looking backwards.” Congressional Democrats, such Rep. John Conyers (D-MI) and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), have said that Congress should continue to investigate Bush’s torture policies regardless of Obama’s plans.

At the Progressive Media Summit on Capitol Hill yesterday, Marcy Wheeler asked Sen. Carl Levin (D-MI), the chairman of the Senate Armed Forces Committee, about congressional plans to continue investigating torture. “There needs to be, I believe, an accounting of torture in this country,” replied Levin. He then said that he had suggested to Attorney General-nominee Eric Holder that he appoint “an outside person who’s got real credibility” to continue to investigate:

 

LEVIN: We’re going to try to complete this investigation, at least on the DoD side, Ok. But on the intelligence, the CIA side, that’s going to be up to the Intelligence Committe. I know I suggested to Eric Holder, who will be the next Attorney General despite the delay that took place today, that he select some people or hire an outside person whose got real credibility, perhaps a retired federal judge, to take all the available information, and there’s reams of it.

And in all of the ‘debate’ over whether we should ignore torture and detention by ‘moving forward,’ nobody seems to be talking about one aspect….the victims….of the Bush Administration torture policy. It serves the purpose of the torturers to highlight KSM and other (still not tried and found guilty) ‘bad guys.’ But we need to remember always that MOST of the people swept up in their net SEEM (again, no trials) to be quite innocent. And thus have been released. Such as…

From Reza Sayah

CNN

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan (CNN) – Muhammad Saad Iqbal is a free man after

serving more than six years at the U.S. military’s detention facility in

Guantanamo Bay, Cuba – without any charge.

Now, Iqbal is suing the U.S. government for unlawful detention.



“I am angry in my heart,” Iqbal said in a recent interview. “It’s easy

for the U.S. government to say, ‘There are no charges found and he’s free.’

“But who will be responsible for seven years of my life?”

Plus, check out this amazing clip of a former detainee and former Gitmo guard talking together on BBC!

22 comments

Skip to comment form

  1. Photobucket

    To find that the NSA was spying on every American in a huge illegal dragnet. I am working on a piece tying it all together into a picture of our government gone wild, but I think we should wait for the next big push til after Holder makes it through the Repub obstacle course….what do you guys think?

  2. I think that’s part of the reason Obama and Biden are being somewhat coy about prosecutions.  I think that he’s approaching many things from this perspective.

    If they come in on day one screaming about how everything has to change and making drastic changes immediately, they will only provoke the right wing in gov’t, media and public.

    I think it’s wise to lay back a little and build up some steam before introducing the bigger changes.  Hopefully, a slow continuous effort towards the goals will both work and not alarm the public.

  3. Top UN Official Calls for Indictment of Bush and Rumsfeld

    Thu, 2009-01-22 03:34.

    Top UN official calls for indictment of Bush and Rumsfeld

    The incoming American President Barack Obama is legally obligated to prosecute Bush and Rumsfeld because the US has ratified the UN Convention on Torture and has also recognized it as legally binding, UN Special Rapporteur on Torture Manfred Nowak said.

    The UN Special Rapporteur on Torture Manfred Nowak urged the indictment of outgoing US President George W. Bush and his former secretary of defense Donald Rumsfeld for their role in the torture and abuse of prisoners in the Guantanamo prison camp.

    “The evidence is on the table,” Nowak told German television Tuesday.

    He held Bush and Rumsfeld responsible for the brutal interrogation methods and the inhuman treatment of prisoners at Guantanamo.

    “One should not quibble, it was torture,” Nowak stressed.

    The incoming American President Barack Obama is legally obligated to prosecute Bush and Rumsfeld because the US has ratified the UN Convention on Torture and has also recognized it as legally binding, he said.

    “Therefore they must do everything they can that persons who are accused of torture, are put on trial,” added Nowak who published a UN report in 2006 on the situation in Guantanamo.

    Nowak charged the US in the report with violating international human rights standards.

    Many interrogation methods led to the torture of Guantanamo inmates, the UN official said.

  4. DOJ Considering a Special Counsel to Probe Bush Torture Policies        

    Written by Jason Leopold    

    Wednesday, 21 January 2009 13:57  

    By Jason Leopold

    The Department of Justice is giving “serious thought” to a proposal by a leading Democratic lawmaker to appoint a special counsel to conduct a criminal probe into the interrogation practices enacted during the Bush administration, according to three DOJ lawyers.

    These DOJ attorneys said consideration is being given to the idea of expanding a special prosecutor’s current investigation into the destruction of the CIA’s torture tapes to include a probe into the interrogation methods, such as waterboarding, that are depicted on the tapes to determine whether federal torture laws were broken. U.S. Attorney John Durham, who was appointed by former Attorney General Michael Mukasey last year to investigate the destruction of the CIA’s torture tapes had only been given the authority to probe the destruction of the tapes. . . .

    and,

    Rep. Tammy Baldwin Asks Colleagues to Hold Bush Gang Accountable

    Congresswoman Tammy Baldwin just sent this letter to her colleagues in the Congressional Progressive Caucus. Please phone your representative about it.

    Executive Branch Accountability from Progressive Caucus member Tammy Baldwin

    January 22, 2009

    Dear Colleague:

    This week, President Barack Obama stood before the American people and took an oath of office to “…preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.” Along with this oath, it is my hope that he will take the actions detailed in legislation I plan to introduce, the Executive Branch Accountability Act of 2009, which I believe will help in his work to restore the public’s faith in our government.

    Over the past several years, serious questions have been raised about the conduct of high ranking Bush/Cheney Administration officials in relation to some of the most basic elements of our democracy: respect for the rule of law, the principle of checks and balances, and the fundamental freedoms enshrined in the Bill of Rights. The list of abuses of executive branch power is long, as are the Bush/Cheney Administration’s attempts to impede congressional oversight.

    President Obama has already begun the work or reaffirming American values of justice and freedom. I commend him for announcing his intention to close the Guantanamo Bay Detention Center and nominating a candidate for Attorney General who understands torture has no place in our great nation. I believe part of President Obama’s effort to renew America must include restoring executive branch accountability, and that he can take some simple steps to proactively prevent any further abuses of executive branch power by his or future administrations. . . .

  5. from collective amnesia? I remember every moment every crime every sick death worship perpetuated by us all in the last decade. Make that forever from the start. Let’s see, a bunch of guys with box cutters from Egypt and Saudis America kill 3,000 people and we use this as a reason to kill torture and bomb thousands of humans, untold deaths untold misery for humans like us because we say ‘bring it on! How dare you threaten our precious life style. The one that kills both humans and nature, the one that lets people roam homeless dependent on faith which advocates inhumanism.

    The piles of bodies the hooded victims,where do they go? They were not real? They were ‘bad’. Lordy let us at least acknowledge human rights those that do no meet our criterion of interest. We all share the same interest. Use our Laws, Obama, they are the only thing that will bring us out of the dark into the family of man. We cannot justify nor pave this over. Politics are not law, this cannot be moved beyond. Do the right thing, bring on the light.      

    • RUKind on January 23, 2009 at 06:52

    We’re passing through a black-hole vortex of global crises. He needs to be taking care of Now and What’s Coming Next. Conyers and Congress and the Senate should be cleaning up the mess that was made on their watch.

    The Repugs will spin this as partisan politics as usual. If Obama lets the legislators take the lead on this then he can stay above the fray and get his job done. And doing his job will require some Republican support.

    This president is brilliant.

    Then again, without us pushing from behind every day and in every way, this whole shit pile we’re trying to hump up and over the mountaintop may roll back down on us.

    Now the bricks lay on Grand Street

    Where the neon madmen climb.

    They all fall there so perfectly,

    It all seems so well timed.

    An’ here I sit so patiently

    Waiting to find out what price

    You have to pay to get out of

    Going through all these things twice.


    Oh, Mama, can this really be the end,

    To be stuck inside of Mobile

    With the Memphis blues again.

    B. Dylan

Comments have been disabled.